To Build a Wall and Then Take It Down

Photos by Robert Banat:   RobertBanat.com  RobertBanat@gmail.com

FOURTH GRADERS WENT  TO WASHINGTON SQUARE PARK on the second day of school and participated in an art installation with the artist, Bosco Sodi.

On the day of the trip, we let students know we were going on a mystery walk and we did not give them any background information beyond the fact that an artist, Bosco Sodi, would be there creating a piece of art in a public space. Their job was to make sense of it.

When we arrived in the park, the artist and his team were in full swing building a wall with timbers made in Mexico by local artisans. Fourth graders perched close by with their clipboards and took notes. 

Soon enough, the artist, Bosco Sodi, offered students the opportunity to join in and help. “Sure!” they chimed. In no time, fourth graders formed an assembly line from the crates of bricks to the growing wall and passed the timbers to their temporary destination. Even our most reserved and careful students were stepping into line. It was a beautiful moment! Students experiencing first-hand that they have powers and a voice.

When we returned to the classroom, students enthusiastically shared their predictions, assessments, and questions. Just as we had hoped, they came up with a spectrum of interpretations ranging from the installation being a community-building event to a protest against the president’s wall proposal. We read more about the project and the artist, including the artist’s statement,

“It’s my first political performance and I just felt I had to do it now. I wanted to show that any wall is dismantlable. We, the public, can tear down walls when society gets together. It could be a mental, physical, or political wall – the point is, it’s ephemeral.”

We also found out that the bricks were boxed up in Mexico and traveled to New York via a route often taken by undocumented migrants.

That afternoon, at 3:00 the wall was dismantled. Timbers were given away to anyone who wanted one. We have one in our classroom now as a reminder of our special experience and as a metaphor to consider as we learn more about historical and contemporary immigration.

The next day, students wrote letters to the artist. Of course they were filled with thoughtfulness. We include just a few examples here. If you would like to see all of the letters, copies of them are all posted on the bulletin board outside of our classroom. We sent the originals to the artist.

Dear Mr. Sodi,

Hello my name is Cy. I saw “Muro.” I thought it was really cool. I noticed that you put lots of hard work and effort into making it. I think people should respect that. I felt really helpful because I helped make “Muro.” It felt good to be helpful.

“Muro,” made me think that projects could build community. I went back later that day and got three timbers. I think it’s interesting that you signed every timber. It was like each timber got your autograph on it. What gave you the idea to make “Muro”? I would really like to know. I hope you make more cool projects like this.

Sincerely,

Cy


PS: I just heard about the earthquake. I hope everything is okay.

 

Dear Mr. Sodi,

My name is Hanako and I really like the art that you made in Washington Square Park. I saw when you were building the wall you fit the clay timbers in very well, it reminded me of the work of a Japanese carpenter! When I was helping build the wall I felt like I was helping a lot of people and at least making a small difference in the world.

 

The experience made me think about how confused I am about the fact that Trump wants to build a wall and make Mexico pay for it. What gave you the idea of the specific protest? One more thing, you have really inspired me to think about the problems in the world a lot more.

Sincerely,

Hanako

 

 

Dear Bosco Sodi,

I really liked your wall. I noticed how the wall was built. When I got there I was confused because I didn’t know the wall was there. I thought about what the wall could represent.

I connected your wall to how the world was built by community. A question I have for you is, you have homes in NYC and Mexico but where were you born?

I really liked your art.

Sincerely,

Harley

Dear Mr. Sodi,

I am Theo from LREI. I thought the installation was really cool because you made 1,600 timbers and made it into a wall. Being there felt really awesome because it was a very good way to protest about Trump’s wall. That wall made me think about Trump’s wall and it looks like you were building it. It looks like my wall at home. Why did you do it in Washington Square Park? I think you gave away the timbers because you wanted people to remember to help the people in Mexico.

Love,

Theo

First Day of School: About Me Poems

Theo

 

Theo is dark blue

He’s a baby leopard

He’s sunny and cool in the summer

A comfy sock

A big soft bed

He’s a baseball video game

A juicy raspberry

Sonia

 

Sonia is violet purple

She’s a jumpy Siberian shorthair hamster

She’s a calm autumn morning

A new pair of heels, bright and shiny

A nap on a bunk bed

She’s color switch on a phone

A California sushi roll

Sebastian

 

Sebastian is sky blue

He’s a strong tiger

He’s sledding on a winter day

A Go Bananas shirt

A book shelf of white

He’s playing with his squishy donut

A simply scrumptious sushi roll

Sarah

 

Sarah is turquoise

She’s slick fast fox

She’s a hot humid summer day with a nice breeze

A pair of snuggly warm fuzzy pajamas

A big fluffy bed

She’s a big book you can sink into and become a story

Some fluffy matzo meal pancakes

Saffron

 

Saffron is neon green

She’s a sparkly unicorn

She’s a cold winter

A pair of jean shorts

A big fluffy bed

She’s addicted to her phone

A yummy sushi roll

Palma

 

Palma is lavender purple

She’s a happy Saluki dog

She’s a warm spring morning

A cashmere sweater cozy and warm

A cozy comfy soft warm bed

A bowl of spaghetti nice and yummy

Macy

 

Macy is neon green

She’s a little monkey

She’s a light sprinkle of snow

A big bunk bed

She’s a big inspirational book

A little salty edamame

Libi

 

Libi is strawberry red

She’s a domestic fuzzy alpaca

She’s a summer heat with sudden breezes

A pair of silk pants bouncing up and down on your legs

A warm bed waiting for a cold person to jump in

She’s a book ready to be opened up and read

A delicious bowl of Greek salad with salty feta cheese

Henry

 

Henry is light turquoise

He’s a brown baby beaver

He’s a windy fall day

A red flash hat

A white bunk bed but the bottom bunk is a desk

He’s a lego Star Wars

A yummy Percy’s pizza

Harley

 

Harley is pastel yellow

She’s a light brown adult alpaca

She’s a cold and windy day in autumn

A blue sweater with a cloud on it

A comfy white egg chair

She’s a hedgehog beanbag

A plate of macaroni and cheese

Hanako

 

Hanako is emerald green

She is a giant panda

She’s a cool breeze in autumn

A new jean jacket

A twenty year old couch

She’s an old teddy bear

A plate of mac and cheese from LREI

Giselle

 

Giselle is a midnight black sky

She runs like a white horse running through the wind

She’s a cold winter night when the owls are hooting

A pearly white dress through the soft cold air

A soft breezy bed ready for a great night

She’s a handmade wooden doll

A hot tasty pasta waiting on the table.

Cy

 

Cy is bright neon green

He’s a furry, sluggish, slovenly sloth

He’s a thrilling cold winter

An orange and white western bull baseball cap

A big comfy bed

He’s a world of D and D layed out

A hot hotdog with ketchup, mustard, and relish

Cece

 

Cece is light blue

She’s an English Bulldog

She’s a sunny summer day

A colorful pair of exercise pants

A soft big bed

She’s a skateboard

A big red watermelon

Bo

 

Bo is forest green

He is a black farm duck

He is slow snow falling all day

A yellow and purple striped tie

A big fluffy brown couch

He’s a great big box of legos

A salmon sushi no spicey stuff over rice with soy sauce

Bayo

 

Bayo is dark teal blue

He’s a fast tall bronco

He’s a light rain but not drizzling and warm

A Neymar kit with blue Neymar shoes

A bed with fluffy pillows

He’s a boy playing Fifa17

An Italian sausage in a sandwich

Arlo

 

Arlo is sky blue

A cute beagle

He is spring on a sunny day

He wears a black guard’s hat from Buckingham palace

A chair at shop

A Playstation4

He’s tuna with olive oil on a plate

Alejandro

 

Alejandro is neon green

He’s a water buffalo attracted only to the ocean

He’s a dark blurry snow day in winter

A black and white pair of Air Jordans

A red personal bed

He’s a lego demon

A cooked crocodile tail you get in New Orleans