Name: Henry Toll Humanities
7th Grade Comparative Essay
Outline for Crucible/McCarthy Comparative Essay
Theme: Hysteria and misuse of power
Paragraph #1: Introductory Paragraph (GIT)
Grabber Statement (G):
Imagine you had everything you ever wanted. Imagine that you had an amazing house and everyone respected you. You did not have to do anything and had many people helping you. Then imagine that all of this would disappear in an instant and you would be jailed or have almost nothing. You would be shamed and a person that was almost abandoned by your family. The only way you could stop this is by keeping people in jail or hanging them. What would you do?
Introduction of Theme (I):
Throughout American history there has been much fear of change, but change is how as a human race we move forward. Some of the main moments this happened in American history were the Salem witch trials, the McCarthy era, and current day. An easy way to make the majority feel safe is by doing witch hunts or singling out a whole minority as bad to make those minorities feel unsafe.
Thesis Statement (T):
When hysteria is happening, a power hungry leader misuses her or his power to stay in control and by doing so, feeds the hysteria.
_________________________________________________________________________
Paragraph #2: Crucible Thematic Connection
Topic Sentence (T): In The Crucible Danforth uses hysteria and people’s fear of witches to keep himself in power.
Explanatory Sentence (E): There’s so much hysteria about witches that people can not see through the lies of the girls. This shows how easy it is for a group of people to lose their minds in the face of danger. This hysteria becomes truly crazy when Danforth starts accusing hundreds of people of witchcraft.
Evidence (E): Another example of Danforth misusing his power is on page 92 “And do you know that near to four hundred are in the jails from Marblehead to Lynn, and upon my signature? And seventy-two condemned to hang?”
Analysis (A): This shows that Danforth is misusing his power. He is willing to put innocent people in jail in order to stay in power. Even when he is shown proof he denies it or tries to find a way out of it. This man should be more open minded and should look through the lies. But because of his religion and wanting the faith of the people he doesn’t even think the girls are pretending. If he feeds their hysteria with his power then he gets more power, it is a never stopping loop of chaos. He gains control from hysteria, because their religion says he has power to see through witchcraft . So when he encourages this, they think that God approves of it and that it is holy and good. Then when Abigail accused the people that were proving Danforth wrong, he immediately threw them in jail. When people start not to believe in the witches, he tries to bargain with people for life if they confess that they were witches or wizards. He is always trying to make himself look good and everyone else bad.
Concluding/ Transition (C): Danforth’s style of getting power from hysteria and fear is shown again with McCarthy.
__________________________________________________________________________
Paragraph #3: McCarthy/Red Scare Thematic Connection
Topic Sentence (T):
In the 1950’s Joseph McCarthy used the hysteria of the threat of communism to make false accusations and blacklist innocent people.
Explanatory Sentence (E):
After World War 2, in America there was a Red Scare which means fear of communism. The USSR had nuclear weapons with warheads which could be launched across the world. The intense fear of communism was fuelled by McCarthy. He used fear to make a hysteria to empower himself.
Evidence (E):
He used tactics that are immoral and malicious, an example of one is on page 1, “ I have here in my hand a list of 205 [Men} that were known to the secretary of state as being members of the Communist Party,” but all of the accusations were false.
Analysis (A):
He used the list of names as an example many times and made hysteria from it. This shows how he misused his power as a senator. To keep himself in authority, he kept going with the lies and scapegoating more and more people. This is a tactic that has often been used throughout history by many power hungry people in order to stay in power.
Concluding/ Transition (C):
I think this is a tactic that is being used today by our current president, Donald. J. Trump.
__________________________________________________________________________
Paragraph #4: Modern Day Witch Hunt Thematic Connection
Topic Sentence (T):
Currently Donald. J. Trump is using the tactics of hysteria and fear to single out whole races and calling them bad things.
Explanatory Sentence (E):
He has used his power and influence to make fear of terrorism to gain power. He says many things he will do, and to keep himself in power he does almost all of them. He does not care for America, but what he can get out of being president.
Evidence (E): An example is on the article on npr in the politics section tilted Countries Listed On Trump’s Refugee Ban Don’t Include Those He Has Business With it says “President Donald Trump’s refugee ban in the Middle East could be one of the first conflicts of interest for the president, as his bans avoided nations that he has business ties in.”
Analysis (A): This also shows his misuse of power because you are not allowed to have business ties while in office. He has many ties with companies and has acted on them, which is so illegal. People believe a lot of what he says because he is a famous, rich, successful person in the business world. He has used this influence to create fear and hysteria of everything he does not like.
Concluding/ Transition (C): In conclusion, Donald Trump may be the worst out of all of them.__________________________________________________________________________
Paragraph #5: Paragraph (ROC)
Reflection on Thesis (R):
Fear is one of human beings’ worst emotions because it causes people to become caught up in hysteria. Empowered people can become corrupted because they may find a way to bend this fear into their favor. They do not care who they hurt, but what they get out of it. This has happened many times throughout history, even now with our enlightened society.The quote “power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely,” by John Dalberg-Acton is very true in American history.
Overview of Main Points (O):
An example of this is the Salem Witch Trials because Danforth and Abigail found a way to control people by using their fear of witches against them. Danforth used his power to throw anyone who opposed him in jail. Another example is the second red scare because McCarthy used the American people’s fear of the USSR and communism to make himself very powerful. Sadly, this is still happening today. Trump has used the fear of terrorism to make false accusations and seize power.
Concluding Idea (C):
In conclusion, humans need to adapt more when they are faced with change because adapting is how we survive. We need to be more open minded and make up our own minds with true stories, rather than just buy someone else’s opinion. That is how these leader take over. They have crazy lies, but people buy them and don’t check if it is true. Would you have voted for Donald Trump if you did not know anything but his opinion? Or would you have thought to yourself that doesn’t sound real? Even if there were people dying because of something? Be honest.
Reflection of Outline Essay
In my opinion, my essay is well formatted and dives deeply into thoughtfulness. It is not well said or edited yet, but it has good content. The outline helps me stupendously because it helped me know in which order to write things and how my teacher wanted the essay formatted. When I say the outline helps me know in which order to write, I mean that it shows me where to put sentences and how to put them in the best order. For example, my past essay on The Giver was good before editing. But, since I didn’t have this outline, I had to go back and rearrange my words and paragraphs into the proper order before finishing it. I think that this outline is a very good format tool for an essay, because it is simple at first, but then pushes your thoughts to go deeper. I think this is good because at first you just have to start writing and get your ideas out, but then later you need to improve your writing and thoughts. In conclusion, I am satisfied with my outline for this essay and am happy to move on to the fun stuff, editing.